Ninja Creami vs Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker: Which One You Should Get

I bought both the Ninja Creami and Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker last summer when my family’s ice cream addiction reached new heights. After spending months testing both machines with countless recipes, I’m sharing my honest comparison to help you decide which one deserves space in your kitchen.

Homemade ice cream gives you total control over ingredients and flavors, but these two machines take completely different approaches to frozen treats.

I’ll break down exactly how they differ, what each does best, and which one might be right for your specific needs.

The Fundamentals: How Each Machine Works

Ninja Creami: The Freezer-First Approach

The Ninja Creami works completely differently than traditional ice cream makers. Instead of churning liquid ingredients as they freeze, you:

1. Mix your ingredients in one of the included pint containers
2. Freeze the mixture solid for 24 hours
3. Place the frozen pint into the machine
4. Select your program (ice cream, gelato, sorbet, etc.)
5. The machine’s powerful paddle shaves through the frozen block, creating tiny ice crystals

This process is closer to what commercial $7000 Pacojet machines do in professional kitchens rather than traditional home ice cream makers.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change.

Cuisinart: The Traditional Churning Method

Cuisinart ice cream makers follow the conventional approach:

1. Pre-freeze the insulated bowl for 24 hours
2. Prepare your ice cream base (often involves cooking)
3. Chill the prepared base
4. Pour chilled base into the frozen bowl
5. Turn on the machine and let it churn for 20-25 minutes
6. Transfer soft ice cream to another container to firm up in freezer

The machine slowly churns the mixture while the frozen bowl gradually freezes it, incorporating air throughout the process.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product availability may vary.

Specifications Comparison

Here’s how the basic specs compare between these two popular models:

Feature	Ninja Creami (NC301)	Cuisinart ICE-21
Dimensions	6.52″ L x 12.07″ W x 15.95″ H	9″ L x 9.25″ W x 11.25″ H
Weight	13 lbs	9.9 lbs
Capacity	16 oz (pint)	1.5 quarts (48 oz)
Programs	7 one-touch programs	Simple on/off switch
Wattage	800 watts	60 watts
Price	$160–180	$70–95
Overrun (air added)	About 19%	About 40%
Processing time	~5 minutes (after 24hr freeze)	~25 minutes (after 24hr bowl freeze)
Warranty	1 year	3 years

Size, Storage and Capacity

Ninja Creami: Slim but Tall

The Ninja Creami has a smaller footprint on your counter, similar to the width of a toaster. However, it stands quite tall at almost 16 inches, which might make it challenging to store under kitchen cabinets. It weighs about 13 pounds, making it sturdy but also somewhat hefty to move around.

The major limitation is batch size – you’re restricted to making one pint (16 ounces) at a time. This makes the Creami better suited for:

• Small households
• People who want variety rather than quantity
• Those with dietary restrictions who need customized portions

Cuisinart: Wide but Productive

The Cuisinart ice cream makers (particularly the popular ICE-21 model) have a wider footprint but aren’t as tall as the Ninja Creami. At 9″ x 9.25″, it takes up more counter space but fits more easily under cabinets.

The biggest advantage is capacity – you can make 1.5 quarts (48 ounces) in the ICE-21 or 2 quarts (64 ounces) in the ICE-30BC model. That’s 3-4 times the volume of the Ninja Creami in a single batch, making it ideal for:

• Families
• Entertaining guests
• Making large batches for special occasions

Price Consideration

Ninja Creami: Premium Investment

The Ninja Creami usually retails between $160-180 for the standard 7-in-1 model, while the deluxe versions cost over $200. This puts it in the higher price range for home ice cream makers.

You’ll also need to factor in additional costs:

• Extra pint containers (comes with only 2-3 depending on model)
• Storage space in your freezer for the pint containers

Cuisinart: Budget-Friendly Classic

The Cuisinart ICE-21 typically costs between $70-95, making it significantly more affordable than the Ninja Creami. The ICE-30BC model runs slightly higher but still under $100 in most cases.

Additional considerations:

• Freezer space needed for the bowl
• Only one batch per freeze cycle unless you purchase extra freezer bowls

Functionality and Features

Ninja Creami: Versatility Champion

The Ninja Creami offers impressive versatility with 7 one-touch programs:

1. Ice Cream
2. Sorbet
3. Gelato
4. Milkshake
5. Smoothie Bowl
6. Lite Ice Cream
7. Mix-in

These settings adjust the machine’s speed, pressure, and timing to create different textures for each frozen treat. The “Re-spin” function allows you to process again if you want a creamier texture.

One of the most impressive aspects is the ability to create healthy alternatives:

• Low sugar options
• Keto-friendly treats
• Dairy-free varieties
• Vegan ice creams

Cuisinart: Simple but Effective

The Cuisinart ice cream makers are straightforward with just an on/off switch. This simplicity has advantages:

• Less to break down or malfunction
• Straightforward operation
• No learning curve

While it lacks preset programs, the Cuisinart excels at traditional ice cream making. The motor powers the bowl rotation rather than the paddle, which creates an efficient mixing system that powers through thickening mixtures effectively.

Time Requirements and Planning

Ninja Creami: Quick Processing, Prior Planning

The Ninja Creami workflow:

• Mix ingredients: 5-10 minutes
• Freeze pint: 24 hours
• Processing time: 2-5 minutes
• Ready to eat: Immediately

Total active time is minimal, but you need to plan 24 hours ahead. The huge advantage is that once processed, the ice cream is ready to eat immediately with a perfect scoopable consistency.

Cuisinart: Multi-Stage Process

The Cuisinart workflow:

• Freeze bowl: 24 hours
• Prepare base (may involve cooking): 15-30 minutes
• Chill base: 4-24 hours
• Processing/churning time: 20-25 minutes
• Additional freezing time: 1-4 hours for firm consistency

Total process can span 2-3 days from start to finish, with more active preparation time. The churned result is soft-serve consistency that typically needs additional freezing.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Ninja Creami: Dishwasher-Friendly

The Ninja Creami’s parts are top-rack dishwasher safe, including:

• Containers/pints
• Storage lids
• Creamerizer paddle

This makes cleanup relatively quick and simple. The base unit can be wiped down with a damp cloth.

Cuisinart: Hand-Wash Required

Most Cuisinart ice cream maker parts need hand washing:

• Freezer bowl (once thawed)
• Paddle/dasher
• Lid

This adds some time to the cleanup process, though it isn’t particularly difficult.

Texture and Quality Results

Ninja Creami: Ultra-Smooth Texture

The Ninja Creami creates exceptionally smooth ice cream with very small ice crystals due to its grinding approach. The texture is:

• Extremely smooth
• Dense
• Less airy (around 19% air incorporation)
• Similar to gelato in its richness

The “Re-spin” function lets you adjust to your preferred texture on demand. Even better, you can re-process ice cream that’s been in the freezer for days and restore its freshly-made texture.

Cuisinart: Traditional Ice Cream Feel

The Cuisinart produces ice cream with:

• Good smoothness
• Higher air content (around 40% for ICE-21)
• More traditional American ice cream texture
• Light and fluffy consistency

The texture is excellent initially but deteriorates faster in the freezer over time, developing ice crystals after a few days without the option to re-process.

Pros and Cons Summary

Ninja Creami Pros

• Extremely smooth, dense ice cream texture
• Fast processing time once base is frozen
• Dishwasher-safe parts
• Multiple one-touch programs
• Great for dietary restrictions and customization
• Can refresh frozen ice cream to restore texture
• Takes less counter space width-wise
• Good for experimenting with small batches

Ninja Creami Cons

• More expensive ($160+)
• Limited capacity (16 oz per batch)
• Requires additional pint purchases for versatility
• Learning curve for best results
• Must plan 24 hours ahead
• Taller storage height requirement

Cuisinart Pros

• More affordable ($70-95)
• Makes larger batches (1.5-2 quarts)
• Simple operation
• Lighter weight
• Longer warranty (3 years vs 1 year)
• Traditional ice cream making experience
• No extra containers needed

Cuisinart Cons

• Multi-day process from start to finish
• Hand-wash components
• No programs or timers
• Need to refreeze bowl between batches
• Takes more counter space width-wise
• Ice cream requires additional freezing after churning
• Cannot refresh icy stored ice cream

Which One Should You Get?

Get the Ninja Creami if:

• You want ultra-smooth, professional-quality texture
• You prefer making smaller, more varied batches
• You need to accommodate dietary restrictions
• You value quick processing time and immediate results
• You don’t mind planning 24 hours ahead
• You want the ability to restore texture to frozen treats
• You have a higher budget
• You love experimenting with different flavors and ingredients
• Dishwasher-safe components are important to you

Get the Cuisinart if:

• You need to make larger batches for family or events
• You’re working with a tighter budget
• You enjoy the traditional ice cream making process
• You have space to store the wider (but shorter) appliance
• You value simplicity and fewer moving parts
• You don’t mind the multi-day process
• You want a longer warranty period

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product availability may vary.

Perfect User Matches

The Ninja Creami is perfect for:

• Health-conscious individuals making protein ice creams
• People with dietary restrictions (keto, dairy-free, vegan)
• Singles or couples who want variety in small batches
• Those who value texture quality above all else
• People who want the ability to process multiple flavors in one session
• Impatient types who want quick results once ingredients are frozen

The Cuisinart is perfect for:

• Families needing larger serving sizes
• Traditional ice cream enthusiasts
• Budget-conscious shoppers
• Those who enjoy cooking and the complete process
• People who entertain and need bigger batches
• Those who prefer simplicity over multiple settings

My Personal Experience

I’ve used both machines extensively, and they each have their place depending on what I’m making. When I’m creating special diet treats for friends with restrictions or testing new flavor combinations, the Ninja Creami is my go-to. The small batch size means I’m not wasting ingredients on experiments, and the ability to transform almost anything frozen into a creamy treat is downright magical.

However, when I’m making ice cream for a family gathering or summer party, the Cuisinart’s larger capacity is invaluable. I can make one big batch rather than processing multiple pints in the Creami. The texture is perfectly acceptable, even if it doesn’t reach the silky perfection of the Creami.

Final Verdict

There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here. Both machines make excellent frozen desserts but in completely different ways and with different end results.

If texture quality and dietary flexibility matter most to you, and you don’t mind the higher price tag, the Ninja Creami delivers exceptional results. Its ability to create ultra-smooth ice cream from a wide range of ingredients makes it the clear winner for customization enthusiasts.

If you prioritize quantity, traditional ice cream making, and value for money, the Cuisinart is the smarter choice. It’s been a reliable kitchen workhorse for decades for good reason.

Some ice cream lovers even end up with both machines eventually – using the Cuisinart for large batches of traditional favorites and the Ninja Creami for specialty items and experiments.

Whichever you choose, you’ll be enjoying homemade frozen treats that blow away most store-bought options – and isn’t that the sweetest outcome of all?